Autonomous landing of fixed-wing aircraft on mobile platforms

E n esta tesis se propone un nuevo sistema que permite la operación de aeronaves autónomas sin tren de aterrizaje. El trabajo está motivado por el interés industrial en aeronaves con la capacidad de volar a gran altitud, con más capacidad de carga útil y capaces de aterrizar con viento cruzado. El enfoque seguido en este trabajo consiste en eliminar el sistema de aterrizaje de una aeronave de ala fija empleando una plataforma móvil de aterrizaje en tierra. La aeronave y la plataforma deben sincronizar su movimiento antes del aterrizaje, lo que se logra mediante la estimación del estado relativo entre ambas y el control cooperativo del movimiento. El objetivo principal de esta Tesis es el desarrollo de una solución práctica para el aterrizaje autónomo de una aeronave de ala fija en una plataforma móvil. En la tesis se combinan nuevos métodos con experimentos prácticos para los cuales se ha desarrollado un sistema de pruebas específico. Se desarrollan dos variantes diferentes del sistema de aterrizaje. El primero presta atención especial a la seguridad, es robusto ante retrasos en la comunicación entre vehículos y cumple procedimientos habituales de aterrizaje, al tiempo que reduce la complejidad del sistema. En el segundo se utilizan trayectorias optimizadas del vehículo y sincronización bilateral de posición para maximizar el rendimiento del aterrizaje en términos de requerimientos de longitud necesaria de pista, pero la estabilidad es dependiente del retraso de tiempo, con lo cual es necesario desarrollar un controlador estabilizador ampliado, basado en pasividad, que permite resolver este problema. Ambas estrategias imponen requisitos funcionales a los controladores de cada uno de los vehículos, lo que implica la capacidad de controlar el movimiento longitudinal sin afectar el control lateral o vertical, y viceversa. El control de vuelo basado en energía se utiliza para proporcionar dicha funcionalidad a la aeronave. Los sistemas de aterrizaje desarrollados se han analizado en simulación estableciéndose los límites de rendimiento mediante múltiples repeticiones aleatorias. Se llegó a la conclusión de que el controlador basado en seguridad proporciona un rendimiento de aterrizaje satisfactorio al tiempo que suministra una mayor seguridad operativa y un menor esfuerzo de implementación y certificación. El controlador basado en el rendimiento es prometedor para aplicaciones con una longitud de pista limitada. Se descubrió que los beneficios del controlador basado en el rendimiento son menos pronunciados para una dinámica de vehículos terrestres más lenta. Teniendo en cuenta la dinámica lenta de la configuración del demostrador, se eligió el enfoque basado en la seguridad para los primeros experimentos de aterrizaje. El sistema de aterrizaje se validó en diversas pruebas de aterrizaje exitosas, que, a juicio del autor, son las primeras en el mundo realizadas con aeronaves reales. En última instancia, el concepto propuesto ofrece importantes beneficios y constituye una estrategia prometedora para futuras soluciones de aterrizaje de aeronaves.In this thesis a new landing system is proposed, which allows for the operation of autonomous aircraft without landing gear. The work was motivated by the industrial need for more capable high altitude aircraft systems, which typically suffer from low payload capacity and high crosswind landing sensitivity. The approach followed in this work consists in removing the landing gear system from the aircraft and introducing a mobile ground-based landing platform. The vehicles must synchronize their motion prior to landing, which is achieved through relative state estimation and cooperative motion control. The development of a practical solution for the autonomous landing of an aircraft on a moving platform thus constitutes the main goal of this thesis. Therefore, theoretical investigations are combined with real experiments for which a special setup is developed and implemented. Two different landing system variants are developed — the safety-based landing system is robust to inter-vehicle communication delays and adheres to established landing procedures, while reducing system complexity. The performance-based landing system uses optimized vehicle trajectories and bilateral position synchronization to maximize landing performance in terms of used runway, but suffers from time delay-dependent stability. An extended passivity-based stabilizing controller was implemented to cope with this issue. Both strategies impose functional requirements on the individual vehicle controllers, which imply independent controllability of the translational degrees of freedom. Energy-based flight control is utilized to provide such functionality for the aircraft. The developed landing systems are analyzed in simulation and performance bounds are determined by means of repeated random sampling. The safety-based controller was found to provide satisfactory landing performance while providing higher operational safety, and lower implementation and certification effort. The performance-based controller is promising for applications with limited runway length. The performance benefits were found to be less pronounced for slower ground vehicle dynamics. Given the slow dynamics of the demonstrator setup, the safety-based approach was chosen for first landing experiments. The landing system was validated in a number of successful landing trials, which to the author’s best knowledge was the first time such technology was demonstrated on the given scale, worldwide. Ultimately, the proposed concept offers decisive benefits and constitutes a promising strategy for future aircraft landing solutions

Vision Aided Automatic Landing System for Fixed Wing UAV

Abstract-In this paper, we present a multi-sensor system for automatic landing of fixed wing UAVs. The system is composed of a high precision aircraft controller and a vision module which is currently used for detection and tracking of runways. Designing the system we paid special attention to its robustness. The runway detection algorithm uses a maximum amount of information in images and works with high level geometrical models. It allows detecting a runway under different weather conditions even if only a small part is visible in the image. In order to increase landing reliability under sub-optimal wind conditions, an additional loop was introduced into the altitude controller. All control and image processing is performed onboard. The system has been successfully tested in flight experiments with two different fixed wing platforms at various weather conditions, in summer, fall and winter

High-Fidelity Modeling and Control Design for a Cooperative High Altitude Long Endurance Aircraft Landing System

High Altitude Long Endurance (HALE) aircraft can take flight to altitudes as high as 20 km and can stay there for long periods of time. In this article, the viability of landing such an aircraft on a mobile platform using a cooperative control strategy for motion synchronization is examined. Time domain system identification is applied to create a model of the Elektra 2 Solar HALE aircraft, which was found to be high fidelity by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) standards. An analysis is made to evaluate the feasibility of autonomously landing the HALE Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) on top of a ground vehicle with a roof-mounted landing platform. Controller synthesis is done for the individual vehicles as well as the cooperative landing control, leading to an examination of the overall system stability and performance, using both deterministic and stochastic methods

Vision aided automatic landing system for fixed wing UAV

In this paper, we present a multi-sensor system for automatic landing of fixed wing UAVs. The system is composed of a high precision aircraft controller and a vision module which is currently used for detection and tracking of runways. Designing the system we paid special attention to its robustness. The runway detection algorithm uses a maximum amount of information in images and works with high level geometrical models. It allows detecting a runway under different weather conditions even if only a small part is visible in the image. In order to increase landing reliability under sub-optimal wind conditions, an additional loop was introduced into the altitude controller. All control and image processing is performed onboard. The system has been successfully tested in flight experiments with two different fixed wing platforms at various weather conditions, in summer, fall and winter

Enhancing Model-Free Wind Estimation for Fixed-Wing UAV

Small UAV are often not equipped to measure angle of attack and angle of sideslip, and are therefore not able to determine the local wind vector directly. Model-free wind estimators rely on comparing GPS speed and airspeed measured by a Pitot probe. We propose to enhance such estimators by including approximations of angle of attack and angle of sideslip as pseudo-measurements. Initial flight test results show significant improvements, with errors of the estimated wind in the order of 1 m/s

Smoother Position-Drift Compensation for Time Domain Passivity Approach Based Teleoperation

Despite being one of the most robust methods in bilateral teleoperation, Time Domain Passivity Approach (TDPA) presents the drawback of accumulating position drift between master and slave devices. The lack of position synchronization poses an obstacle to the performance of teleoperation and may prevent the successful accomplishment of such tasks. Several techniques have been developed in order to solve the position-drift problem in TDPA-based teleoperation. However, they either present poor transparency by over-conservatively constraining force feedback or add high impulse-like force signals that can be harmful to the hardware and to the human operator. We propose a new approach to compensate position drift in TDPA-based teleoperation in a smoother way, which keeps the forces within the normal range of the teleoperation task while preserving the level of transparency and the robust stability of energy-based TDPA. We also add a way of tuning the compensator to behave in accordance with the task being performed, whether it requires faster or smoother compensation. The feasibility and performance of the method were experimentally validated. Good position tracking and regular-amplitude forces are demonstrated with up to 500 ms round-trip constant and variable delays for hard-wall contacts

Energy-Based Cooperative Control for Landing Fixed-Wing UAVs on Mobile Platforms Under Communication Delays

The landing of a fixed-wing UAV on top of a mobile landing platform requires a cooperative control strategy, which is based on relative motion estimates. These estimates typically suffer from communication or processing time delays, which can render an otherwise stable control system unstable. Such effects must therefore be considered during the design process of the cooperative landing controller. In this paper the application of a model-free passivity-based stabilizing controller is proposed, which is based on the monitoring of energy flows in the system, and actively dissipating any given active energy by means of adaptive damping elements. In doing so, overall system passivity and consequently stability is enforced in a straightforward and easy to implement way. The proposed control system is validated in numerical simulations for round trip delays of up to 4 seconds

Landing of a Fixed-wing UAV on a Mobile Ground Vehicle

The development of solar-powered high-altitude UAV has gained increasing attention in the recent years. Several aircraft have had successful flights in the stratosphere, but despite advances in lightweight design they can only carry small payloads compared to the total takeoff mass. This paper suggests to eliminate the need for a landing gear by landing on a mobile ground vehicle. This would not only increase the payload capacity, but also simplify landings in crosswind conditions and thus increase the operational availability. A system with a small UAV and a car-mounted landing platform is prepared as a technology demonstrator. Different aspects of the landing problem are studied in simulations and real experiments and algorithms for the cooperative control of both vehicles are proposed. Simulations as well as experiments with the real car and a simulated UAV show the feasibility of such landings